I had never heard of Andrew Sean Greer until a couple months ago when a coworker invited me to come with her to hear him speak at my alma mater – Go Shocks! It was really interesting to hear about his process when he writes, and it was one of the funnest author talks I’ve ever been to (he played the ukulele while reading a section of the book he’s currently working on).
I was really intrigued when he talked about The Confessions of Max Tivoli, which was published in 2004. So I went ahead and bought a copy and even got him to sign it. 🙂 And there are so many things I want to say about this book, but I’ll try to keep it brief.
Max Tivoli was born with something I’ll refer to as the Benjamin Button disease. Quick note though, Greer was actually approached three times to sell this story for the making of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, each time offering him more money, but he declined. I guess we can conclude he received some bad advice. The movie came out about four years after Max Tivoli.
Anyway, Max was born in the body of a seventy year old. He and his family moved around a bit and his parents struggled with his disease. His mother gives him the advice to act how he feels, so a young Max decides to act the age he appears to the world.However, he meets one young boy who’s similar in age, Hughie, and he’s the only one who really knows the truth about Max.
After his father disappears, Max and his mother move back to the home he was born in, but now it’s being rented to several families. This is where Max and Hughie meet Alice. She’s a girl in the lower level of the house, and Max falls in love instantly. So the rest of the book follows Max as he meets Alice at three different times in his life. In the second, he even lies to her about his name and they get married. They spend a few happy years together, until Alice finally leaves him for another man.
The whole story is written by Max at body age twelve as a letter to Alice and his son, Sammy (we don’t find out that they’ve conceived until after Alice has been gone for a few years), explaining everything that’s happened over the last sixty years. Max is actually living with his ex-wife and son, pretending to be an orphaned boy. It’s found about 17 years later in a box in Alice’s attic.
One thing I really like about Greer is that, as a gay man himself, all of his novels have at least one gay character. In Max Tivoli, it turns out to be Hughie who we find out has loved Max, despite his disease, for many years. Hughie loves him until the day he leaves Max, despite all the times Max has been selfish and asked so much of Hughie.
If you haven’t read this book, I really encourage you to do so. You can’t help but feel sorry for Max, even though he’s quite selfish at times. I will admit that I wasn’t expecting what happened at the end, which I think make for the best books. I may have even teared up a little.
-d